- "Well, if you change your mind, I've been told my strawberry daiquiris are sinful."
- —Sherry to Joe West and Cisco Ramon in an attempt to show hospitality[src]
In early 2015, Joe West and Cisco Ramon went to the former Allen house and Sherry, who was wearing considerably revealing at the time, kindly greeted the duo, asking what she can do for them. Joe informed her that they had reopened the investigation of Nora Allen's murder and requested permission to look around the house, which she allowed. She was then seen without a layer of her garment and only in a black dress, asking Joe and Cisco if she could get them something to drink; it became obvious that she was flirting with Joe, much to his bewilderment. Not long after, Joe sent Sherry to the movies so he and Cisco could properly investigate the crime scene without any interruptions or awkward questions.