Hoshaw Tolibao, also known as Brother Hoshaw, is a member of the Church of Blood.
Hoshaw had a previous history of a mental illness, though Abel recruited him for the Church of Blood regardless. This mental illness led him to take a hostage atop Winick Tower with a gun. The Arrow beat up Hoshaw, saving the hostage, and Hoshaw was soon arrested by the cops. He was taken to Starling City Police Department, where he was questioned by Laurel Lance as to why he'd refused a lawyer, giving the reason that he was righteous, therefore he would need no advocate, and he would be protected by his god.