- "It's Sir Stein to you. It's not every actor who's knighted."
- —Henry Stein[src]
In 1895, Stein helped to secure the body of Damien Darhk and helped gather fresh blood in order to sustain it until the blood red moon had risen so that he could be resurrected. He surprised Nate Heywood and helped to kidnap him, strapping him down in his operating room, before leaving to attend a party. At the party, he introduced the order to Eleanor, who he claimed could communicate with the dead. He joined in as Eleanor supposedly channelled Behrad Tomaz. Not long after, Sir Henry attended the ritual ceremony with the order as they prepared to witness Darhk's resurrection. When the blood moon was at its peak, Darhk was fully resurrected. They were interrupted by the Time Bureau, who attempted to arrest Darhk and Eleanor, causing a riot. Stein shot at Zari Tomaz, but was stopped by Rip Hunter. He quickly retreated when the Legends arrived to save Hunter and Tomaz.