- "How much do you know about our previous lives? I reckon not a lot because you didn't recognize me, so let me tell you that we did love other men loved them real and pure, but it never ended well, not ever. Tragedy or heartbreak that's how it always ends if the man's not Carter."
- —Chay-Ara's 19th century reincarnation to Kendra Saunders[src]
The woman sat for a picture with her husband, Hannibal, at the County Fair in 1830. Like her other incarnations, she eventually reclaimed her memories and personal feelings from all her respective past lives. Sometime later, the two of them crossed paths with Vandal Savage in Jefferson City, where they stole Chay-Ara's original bracelet from him. However, they lost it a year later. Hannibal was eventually killed at a young age. While trying to find love again with various men, all admittedly very good people, she could never let go of her feelings for Hannibal, leading her to remain alone and bitter, convinced she would never again feel the same joy she once had with Hannibal.
Living outside of Salvation
The woman eventually came to live in a house some distance outside of the town of Salvation. She was visiting town one day when she accidentally bumped in to her future reincarnation Kendra Saunders, quickly retreating. When Kendra later came looking for her with Sara Lance, despite trying to keep her away, Kendra was able to deduce the woman's identity. They talked of the woman's life with her husband, as well as his future reincarnation Carter Hall. She adamantly voiced her views that they could never find lasting love with any other man besides Khufu's reincarnation.
DC's Legends of Tomorrow
Behind the scenes
- In the DC comics, Chay-Ara had an Old West reincarnation named Katherine Manser, a legendary hero and bounty hunter known as Cinnamon. She was also married to a man named Hannibal Hawkes.